About This Episode
Matt and Michael dive into three recent news stories that have them asking the same question. What is this madness? They break down the California mayoral race, the Anthony Carmelo murder trial, and the Somali World Cup referee denied entry to the US. But the headlines are just the entry point. The real conversation is about something deeper. Why does it feel like half the country has stopped operating in good faith? Why do people defend narratives at the cost of reality itself? And what happens to a culture when it unhooks itself from any higher ideal?
Resources & References
- John C. Lennox — Scottish mathematician and Christian apologist. Known for debates with Richard Dawkins, Christopher Hitchens, and others. Link ↗
- Hillsdale College — Private conservative liberal arts college in Michigan. Their YouTube channel features extensive content on American history and founding principles. Link ↗
- Man on Wire (2008) — Documentary about Philippe Petit, the French high-wire artist who walked between the Twin Towers in 1974. Available on various streaming platforms. Link ↗
- The Screwtape Letters by C.S. Lewis — Classic work of Christian apologetics written as a series of letters from a senior demon to a junior tempter. Link ↗
- Lincoln (2012) — Steven Spielberg film starring Daniel Day-Lewis as Abraham Lincoln during the final months of the Civil War. ) Link ↗
- Am I a Racist? (2024) — Documentary by Matt Walsh investigating the anti-racism industry. Link ↗
- Roland G. Fryer Jr. — Economist at Harvard who published controversial research on racial disparities in police use of force. Link ↗
- Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn — Russian novelist and historian, quoted on the line between good and evil running through every human heart. Link ↗
- Teresa of Avila — Spanish mystic and Carmelite nun, quoted on wanting to want to love God. Link ↗
Threads for Future Episodes
-
"Look at Me" - The Father-Child Dynamic
Michael explicitly bookmarks this at 97:24: "Dude, I feel like there's a whole conversation in that area." Matt agrees: "Well, maybe we should bookmark it." The thread: Jesus telling Peter "look at me" as he sinks into the water connects to the father-child relationship, where "look at me" is life and death when you're young but becomes less legitimate as children grow. They want to explore how this dynamic plays out spiritually, relationally, and culturally.
-
Playing the Part to Become the Part
Referenced at 38:47 when Matt talks about watching high school football players who start out pretending and eventually become the real thing. Michael connects this to his own point about living a lie versus aspiring to become something better. This could be a full conversation about identity formation, discipline, and the gap between who we are and who we want to become.
-
The Moral Circle - Conservatives vs. Liberals
Matt references a graph at 72:21 showing how liberals rate things as more important the farther they are from themselves, while conservatives rate things as more important the closer they are. Michael responds that if you overlapped the two graphs, you'd have full coverage. They agree this tension is beautiful and necessary, but they only scratched the surface. A full episode on moral circles, proximity vs. distance, and how to hold that tension without it becoming perverted.
-
Words, Definitions, and Communication
Matt's extended riff at 85:34 about how we don't use words based on their definitions but on shared understanding, and how bad actors exploit this by swapping definitions without telling anyone. He gives examples: pandemic, vaccine, racism, privilege. This is a rich topic they could return to with more structure.
-
The Kingdom of Heaven
Matt mentions at 25:31 that they could talk about the kingdom of Heaven in the context of narrative protection and reality denial. They never fully got there. This remains an open thread from earlier episodes as well. The Revolutionary War and the 250th anniversary - Matt expresses frustration that the anniversary is being missed as an opportunity for reconciliation. They could do a full episode on founding principles, what makes America unique, and why the founding story matters now. Trust in institutions - Both men agree trust has broken down over the last 6-10 years. They could explore which institutions, why, and whether any are recoverable. Marriage as a model for cultural cooperation - The extended metaphor at 46:12 about marriage requiring a shared external reference point could be expanded into a conversation about covenant, vows, and what makes relationships and societies work. Genocide of reality - Matt's provocative framing at 27:01 about abolishing reality itself being a kind of spiritual genocide. This connects to their ongoing conversations about Cain, the crucifixion, and modern culture wars. John C. Lennox - Matt and Michael both express admiration. A conversation with Lennox about rationality, science, and faith would fit their ongoing thread perfectly. Someone from Hillsdale College - Given how much Matt praises their founding history videos, a historian or professor from Hillsdale could add depth to their American history discussions. Matt Walsh - They reference his documentary *Am I a Racist?* and the confrontation with Robin DiAngelo. Walsh's approach to cultural commentary aligns with their concerns about narrative over reality.